Over the past few years, coffee substitutes have become more popular as people seek out better alternatives to their caffeine fix. Two popular brands in this category are MUDWTR and Ryze. Each provides mushroom-based beverages created to enhance productivity without the downsides often linked to regular coffee.
In this article, we'll analyze these two brands to allow you to decide which could be the better option for your lifestyle.
Ingredients and Formulation
MUDWTR's original blend contains a mix of organic ingredients, such as:
Masala chai
Cacao
Lion's mane mushroom
Chaga mushroom
Cordyceps mushroom
Reishi fungus
Turmeric
Cinnamon
Pink salt
In contrast, Ryze's mushroom coffee blend features:
Arabica coffee
Cordyceps mushroom
Lion's mane mushroom
Reishi fungus
Shiitake fungus
Turkey tail mushroom
King trumpet mushroom
Medium-chain triglyceride oil
Coconut milk powder
Both brands prioritize natural elements and functional fungi. However, their formulations vary. MUDWTR's mix includes more variety, with the addition of herbs and cocoa. Ryze, in contrast, features actual coffee and medium-chain triglycerides, which might be favored by those seeking a more traditional coffee-like experience.
Caffeine Content
A key distinction between the two products is their caffeine content.
MUDWTR has approximately 35 mg of caffeine per serving, which is approximately 1/7th of the caffeine found in an standard coffee mug.
Ryze, in contrast, includes approximately 48 mg of caffeine per serving, which is slightly more than MUDWTR but still considerably less than traditional coffee.
This difference in caffeine content might matter for those who are easily affected by caffeine. MUDWTR might be the better choice for people aiming to significantly cut their caffeine use, while Ryze could be better for those seeking a compromise between traditional coffee and a caffeine-free substitute.
Taste and Flavor Profile
How these beverages taste is dependent on individual tastes, but we can describe some common traits for each.
MUDWTR's original blend is often described as rich and slightly spicy, with undertones of chocolate from the cacao and masala chai characteristics from the spice blend. Certain individuals compare it to a mildly flavored hot chocolate or a chai latte.
Ryze, being a coffee-based product, offers a familiar coffee taste. However, the presence of mushrooms and coconut milk powder creates a novel flavor profile. Some describe it as milder and easier to drink than regular coffee.
Your favorite will likely depend on your desire for something completely different from coffee (MUDWTR) or a beverage reminiscent of regular joe ryze vs mud wtr (Ryze).
Health Benefits
These two products tout numerous nutritional advantages because of their use of adaptogenic mushrooms.
Possible health perks are:
Improved focus and mental clarity
Sustained energy levels
Enhanced immune function
Lower stress levels
Enhanced rest
Antioxidant properties
Keep in mind, however, that although adaptogenic fungi have a long history in holistic health practices, additional studies are required to definitively establish their health benefits.
Price and Value
In terms of pricing, both MUDWTR and Ryze are costlier than regular joe.
Currently, a 30-serving tin of MUDWTR's original blend costs approximately $50, while a 30-day supply of Ryze is priced at around $36.
MUDWTR and Ryze have subscription options that lower the price per serving. Furthermore, they regularly have sales that can make their products more affordable.
Regarding overall value, you should consider beyond the sticker price. If these products help you reduce or eliminate your daily coffee habit, you may end up spending less over time.
Ease of Use
Both MUDWTR and Ryze are formulated for simple to make.
When brewing MUDWTR, you need to mix one tablespoon of the powder to hot water and mix. Lots of people enjoy adding their favorite creamer and a bit of honey to enhance the flavor.
Ryze is prepared in a similar manner. You mix a spoonful of the mix with hot water and stir. Certain individuals report that Ryze dissolves better than MUDWTR, which can leave some sediment.
The two companies offer accessories like frothers to help with mixing, which is particularly useful if you enjoy fancier coffee drinks.
User Feedback and Experiences
The coffee alternatives boast numerous fans and generally positive reviews.
Many MUDWTR users report feeling more focused and energized without the jitters or crash associated with regular coffee. Certain individuals mention that it required an adjustment period to appreciate the unique flavor, but most come to like it with continued use.
Ryze users frequently commend the way it can deliver consistent alertness without coffee's downsides. Lots of people like the flavor that's closer to regular coffee, particularly individuals moving away from daily coffee habits.
Both products have their critics, with some users reporting gastrointestinal problems or minimal impact. Nevertheless, this type of feedback seems to be less common.
Final Thoughts
Choosing between MUDWTR and Ryze boils down to what you're looking for and nutritional needs.
If you want a totally different experience with a unique, spicy flavor and very low caffeine content, MUDWTR might be the better choice.
In contrast, if you like a more familiar taste with slightly higher caffeine content and a smoother texture, Ryze might be more up your alley.
These coffee alternatives boast {potential health